The pad is the most important part of a pair of cycling bib shorts. The main job of bib shorts is to support the foam pad between body and saddle. It’s often called an insert or chamois, on account of early bib shorts using a real leather pad made from chamois goat skin. Yes, really. You used to have to treat it with chamois cream to keep it soft. These days they are mostly made from synthetic materials.
When buying your first pair of bib shorts, remember that most of the money goes into the pad. In theory, the more you spend on a pair of shorts, the better the pad. In practice, this isn’t always the case, so it pays to do your homework carefully. The road.cc bib shorts review archive is the perfect place to start. https://road.cc/category/review-section/clothing/shorts-34s
The pad is shaped to conform to the body and provide padding where you make contact with the saddle. The most important areas are where the sit bones make contact with the saddle. Cheaper shorts might have a single-thickness pad, while the more expensive pads use variable levels of foam thickness and density to keep the pad thinner where you don’t need much cushioning, and thicker where you do need it. Such pads are generally more comfortable as a result.
Look for a pad with an antibacterial finish for hygiene. Some pads have channels or perforations to wick away sweat and encourage the movement of air; there’s nothing more uncomfortable than a soggy pad.
The pad should feel reasonably soft and have some flex to it, so it shapes to your body. It needs to sit flush with your curves. The better pads we’ve tested tend to feel like they’re not there at all.
Manufacturers are now aiming shorts at different riding types, so it’s possible to choose more padding for endurance riding and slimmer pads for shorter rides or racing.
Pads come in men’s and women’s versions, with shapes to suit the different anatomies. No two pads are the same. They can vary in thickness, shape and other factors, so the best thing is to try them on before you buy.
Just like saddles, what works for one person won’t necessarily work for another. We’re all different shapes, and your weight and riding style can influence the type of pad that will work best for you.
Add new comment
6 comments
Had a couple of pairs of Giordana FRC Pro bibs for several seasons now and they have been superb (in ALL the catagories listed!).
As with some of the other Buyer's Guides, the categories do seem a bit shoehorned in.
I struggle to see a significant distinction between "best for luxury", "best for comfortable padding" and "best for sublime comfort". OK, maybe the most comfortable pad might differ from the most comfortable overall, but the criteria for "luxury" and "sublime comfort" appear to be identical - the "luxury" winner's strongest point appers to be it's ‘next-level comfort’, while the "sublime" winner appears to have won partly on the strength of it's 'luxurious' fabric.
And then of course there's the "best money-no-object", the winner of which is also described as being "sublimely comfortable". Is that more or less sublimely comfortable than the "best for sublime comfort"?
My suggestion would be to ditch the "best for..." straplines. If they need straplines, then how about "great for..." - there's only one "best" but several products can be "great" which would avoid this pedantry. If you must have "best" then maybe restrict that to "best overall" (the one you would buy with your own hard earned cash) "best value" (the one you would buy if you were skint) and "best money-no-object" (the one you would choose if a magic genie offered to grant you exactly one pair of bib shorts to wear for all eternity). The rest of the list can be "also recommended" with the review text highlighting what each option's strengths and weaknesses are.
It surprises me why so few haltarneck bib shorts are available for women. On long rides the biggest issue my partner has is being able get her bibs off to go to the loo. Halterneck staps that go around the neck instead of being like braces are much easier to get off quickly. Yet I hardly see any top brands make this style of bibs.
I know loads of female riders who prefer them and wish they could find more so there is a market for them
they don't seem to get reviewed much, but by far the most comfortable shorts i've had have been from Isadore
Any chance you can do best "bib-less" shorts? I really don't like bibs, but seems hard to find good normal cycling shorts these days.
My brother uses Galibier's madison shorts, they are non bib and he seems to likes them.
Currently loving my Assos shorts I got for Christmas.